| Year | League | 
| 
 1896-1912  | 
Independent | 
| 
 1912-1927  | 
Wisconsin Normal Conference | 
| 
 1927-1950  | 
Wisconsin State Teacher’s College Conference | 
| 
 1950-1955  | 
Wisconsin State Universities Conference | 
| 
 1955-1964  | 
Wisconsin State Colleges Conference | 
| 
 1964-1993  | 
Independent | 
| 
 1993-1994  | 
Mid-Continent Conference | 
| 
 1994-2001  | 
Midwestern Collegiate Conference | 
| 
 2001-2012  | 
Horizon League | 
| Coach | Years | Win-Loss | 
| Charles Davies | 1908-1910 | 11-19 | 
| Emmett Angeli | 1910-1914 | 51-17 | 
| Barney Anderson | 1914-1917, 1920-1926  | 
59-76-1 | 
| Paul Stohart | 1917-1918 | 1-9 | 
| George Downer | 1918-1920 | 15-12 | 
| Milton Murray | 1926-1930 | 17-40 | 
| Guy Penwell | 1930-1942, 1946-1952  | 
186-145 | 
| Josh Tierney | 1942-1946 | 34-25 | 
| Russ Rebholz | 1952-1963 | 123-105 | 
| Ray Krzoska | 1963-1970 | 86-87 | 
| Charles Parsley | 1970-1973 | 46-29 | 
| Bill Klucas | 1973-1975 | 22-30 | 
| Bob Gottlieb | 1975-1980 | 62-70 | 
| Bob Voight | 1980-1983 | 51-25 | 
| Ray Swatella | 1983-1987 | 33-74 | 
| Steve Antrim | 1987-1995 | 124-100 | 
| Ric Cobb | 1995-1999 | 28-81 | 
| Bo Ryan | 1999-2001 | 30-27 | 
| Bruce Pearl | 2001-2005 | 86-38 | 
| Rob Jeter | 2005-present | 101-89 |