Skip to main content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Social Work 775 Trauma Counseling II: Diagnosis/Treatment: Evidence-Based Questions

Questions into Searches

Using some basic search logic you can take your PICO question's main concepts of Population, Intervention, and Comparison and plug them into a formula to create a search that will work on most of our disciplinary research databases.

One of the most basic formulas that you can use to make a PICO question work is:

Population AND (Intervention OR Outcome)

in some cases, a population may be more complicated to conceptualize, so here's an example:

"Children with anxiety" AND (medication OR "cognitive behavioral therapy")

because of how this search may turn out, however, we want to think about how to conceptualize our population. Anxiety can be classified a few different ways in medical and psychological literature, so it is important to separate between anxiety as a feeling and anxiety as a disorder. Similarly, with EBP it is often good to become specific with a population if possible, as the medical and psychological communities will divide children into age groups for study purposes.

("School-aged Children" AND "anxiety disorders") AND (medication OR "cognitive behavioral therapy")

COPES Questions

Using the COPES (Client-Oriented, Practical Evidence Search) Framework to Ask Evidence-Based Questions

Copes Questions
 

Client Type and Problem [1]

What you Might Do [2] Alternative Course of Action [3] What you aim to Accomplish [4]

Across:  Four elements of a good question.

-------------------

DOWN: Five Question Types

Describe the group of clients; be specific about characteristics. Apply a treatment; actions to prevent a problem; measures to assess a problem; client surveys; screening to assess risk alternatives or comparisons of interventions to the methods proposed in column [2]. the outcomes of the treatments from [2] and/or [3]. were there valid measures? Accurate risk estimation, prevented behavior, accurate estimation of need?
Effectiveness If disoriented elderly persons living in residential nursing homes are given reality orientation therapy or validation therapy which will result in better orientation to time, place, and person?
Prevention If sexually active high school students at high risk for pregnancy are exposed to sex education that includes instruction on proper use of birth control methods or Baby-Think-It-Over which group will have knowledge of birth control methods/use birth control methods/have fewer pregnancies?
Assessment If aged residents of a nursing home with alzheimer's or dementia may have depression are administered depression screening tests or a short mental status examination which measure will be the briefest, most inexpensive, valid and reliable test to differentiate between depression and dementia?
Description If family members of persons diagnosed with Aphasia meet for a support group and receive a short client satisfaction questionnaire given to all support group participants   which areas will the clients list as their ares of greasts and least satisfaction?
Risk If those calling a crisis line for a battered women's shelter are administered a risk assessment scale via telephone or are assessed only by the answerer's "practical judgement" without a scale then will the risk scale have a higher reliability and predictive validity regarding future violence?

 

Form Your Questions

 

Therapy

Etiology

Diagnosis

Prevention

Prognosis

P – Population or Patient or Disease

Characteristics of a population (age, gender, ethnicity, etc) within a specific condition or set of circumstances. Example: Sudanese Refugees

I -Intervention or Exposure

Specific Drug, therapy, or Procedural Intervention

Exposure to certain conditions or risk behavior

Alternative diagnostic tool or procedure

Specific drug or procedural intervention

Specific drug, therapy, or procedural intervention

C – Comparison

Alternative drug, therapy,  or procedural intervention

Absence of certain conditions or risk behavior

Alternative diagnostic tool or procedure

Alternative drug or procedural intervention

Alternative drug, therapy, or procedural intervention

O – Outcome

Management of disease/condition

Development of disease/condition

Effective diagnosis of condition

Prevention of Disease/condition

Occurrence or absence of new condition

T – Time Frame

The time it takes to demonstrate an outcome or the period in which patient are observed. Examplethe six month period following childbirth.

 

PICO questions are typically used in Nursing and most clinical health research.

Using the COPES (Client-Oriented, Practical Evidence Search) Framework to Ask Evidence-Based Questions

Copes Questions
 

Client Type and Problem [1]

What you Might Do [2] Alternative Course of Action [3] What you aim to Accomplish [4]

Across:  Four elements of a good question.

-------------------

DOWN: Five Question Types

Describe the group of clients; be specific about characteristics. Apply a treatment; actions to prevent a problem; measures to assess a problem; client surveys; screening to assess risk alternatives or comparisons of interventions to the methods proposed in column [2]. the outcomes of the treatments from [2] and/or [3]. were there valid measures? Accurate risk estimation, prevented behavior, accurate estimation of need?
Effectiveness If disoriented elderly persons living in residential nursing homes are given reality orientation therapy or validation therapy which will result in better orientation to time, place, and person?
Prevention If sexually active high school students at high risk for pregnancy are exposed to sex education that includes instruction on proper use of birth control methods or Baby-Think-It-Over which group will have knowledge of birth control methods/use birth control methods/have fewer pregnancies?
Assessment If aged residents of a nursing home with alzheimer's or dementia may have depression are administered depression screening tests or a short mental status examination which measure will be the briefest, most inexpensive, valid and reliable test to differentiate between depression and dementia?
Description If family members of persons diagnosed with Aphasia meet for a support group and receive a short client satisfaction questionnaire given to all support group participants   which areas will the clients list as their ares of greasts and least satisfaction?
Risk If those calling a crisis line for a battered women's shelter are administered a risk assessment scale via telephone or are assessed only by the answerer's "practical judgement" without a scale then will the risk scale have a higher reliability and predictive validity regarding future violence?

 

COPES questions are typically used in Social Work and some other helping professions as a question framework.